Image Commercially Licensed From: DepositPhotos

A Chilling Outlook for Investors

The economic landscape in China, the world’s second-largest economy, has left investors anxious and uncertain. Recent data reveals a worrying trend as China grapples with a decline in foreign investments, marking a significant milestone. This is the first time in 25 years that the country has experienced such a decline, putting into question its ability to attract foreign companies and investments.

The Data Speaks

The stark reality is evident in the numbers. Data published by the State Administration of Foreign Exchange (SAFE) shows that foreign direct investment (FDI) into China has taken a negative turn. In the third quarter of 2022, China’s direct investment liabilities were at a disheartening minus $11.8 billion. This represents a sharp contrast from the third quarter of the previous year, when the figure stood at a more promising $14.1 billion.

 A Troubling Milestone for China

The gravity of the situation becomes apparent when one realizes that this is the first time the gauge has displayed negative values since records began 25 years ago. It is a clear indication that foreign companies are not reinvesting within China, but rather, they are withdrawing their capital from the country.

Defining Direct Investment Liabilities

To understand the implications fully, it’s essential to clarify what “direct investment liabilities” encompass. This category includes profits belonging to foreign companies that have not been repatriated or distributed to shareholders. It also includes foreign investments in financial institutions within China. This negative trend signifies a reluctance to repatriate profits and a decline in foreign investments within the country’s financial sector.

Geopolitical Tensions and Investor Caution

The reasons behind this unsettling trend are multi-fold. Geopolitical tensions undoubtedly play a role in this exodus, as the global political landscape becomes increasingly uncertain. However, foreign companies and investors are also growing cautious of the mounting risks in China. These risks include the possibility of sudden raids and detentions, which add to the sense of insecurity surrounding investments.

Vanguard’s Exit

A poignant example of this trend is Vanguard, the world’s second-largest asset management firm, announcing its plans to close its Shanghai office after December 2023. Vanguard’s decision stems from the sale of its stake in a joint venture with local partner Ant Group. The exit, which was initially reported by Bloomberg, indicates that even industry giants are reevaluating their commitment to the Chinese market.

Beijing’s Struggle

Despite Beijing’s efforts to reverse capital outflows and reassure investors, these attempts have fallen short of restoring confidence. One of the initiatives aimed at portraying China as an open market and improving trade ties, the China International Import Expo (CIIE), faced criticism from the European Union Chamber of Commerce in China. The Chamber described the event as more of a “showcase” than a concrete step towards facilitating foreign investment.

Seeking Solutions

In its endeavor to boost economic growth, China’s government has taken various measures, including approving one trillion yuan in sovereign bonds. These bonds are mainly directed towards funding infrastructure projects. Additionally, China’s sovereign wealth fund intervened in the stock market, one of the poorest performers globally, to help improve its performance.

Furthermore, the relaxation of capital controls in Beijing and Shanghai aimed to encourage foreigners to move their money more freely into and out of the country. The People’s Bank of China also engaged with prominent Western companies like JP Morgan, Tesla, and HSBC, pledging to further open up the financial industry and optimize the operating environment for overseas companies.

Lingering Skepticism

Despite these concerted efforts, global investors remain cautious. China’s increasing scrutiny of Western companies and an ongoing structural economic slowdown contribute to this apprehension. A survey by the American Chamber of Commerce in Shanghai underscored this skepticism, with only 52% of respondents expressing optimism about their five-year business outlook, the lowest level since the survey began in 1999. This figure has dwindled from 55% in 2022 and a robust 78% in 2021, highlighting the ongoing challenges faced by investors in the Chinese market.